From our point of view
Return

HCP Brain Hacks

LinkedIn Share Button

Doctors have feelings that impact decision making just like everyone else.

You know that feeling of being overwhelmed at the grocery store, surrounded by countless choices, knowing you can't spend all day evaluating each one?

Doctors feel it too, sitting in their office, trying to choose the best medication for a patient before their next appointment.

Doctor's treatment decisions are not resistant to the constraints of time and excessive information.

So, how do they adapt?

The way we all do. Using mental shortcuts—a more efficient way of making decisions.

When confronted with excessive information and time constraints,  "mental shortcuts" may shape an HCP's treatment decisions.

SHORTCUT #1 - CONJUNCTION FALLACY

Two is Better Than One

When an HCP notices that Medication X proves to be highly effective for two of their 50-year-old patients, they may conclude that Medication X will be effective for anyone who is 50 and older...

Image: two circle, over lapping in the middle. Left circle labeled "Efficacy", right circle labeled "Age", overlap in the middle labeled "Age + Efficacy" with an arrow pointing up to the text "Connection made by HCP". Text beside: "However, age may be unrelated to the efficacy of the medication.​ HCP Brain Hack. HCP brains are wired to connect independent events in close proximity."
When confronted with excessive information and time constraints, "mental shortcuts" may shape an HCP's treatment decisions.

SHORTCUT #2 - HOT HAND FALLACY

Wins Bring Wins

An HCP observes that Medication X was effective for five consecutive patients over the age of 50, so they assume that the sixth 50-year-old patient will also respond positively to Medication X

HCP's BELIEF diagram: Two rows: Top row labeled "Efficacy" with 6 clip boards across. Each with a checkmark inside. Second row labeled "Patient #" with number 01 through 06 across. Below: REALITY diagram: Two rows: Top row labeled "Efficacy" with 6 clip boards across. 5 with a checkmark inside, the 6th faded/lighter. Second row labeled "Patient #" with number 01 through 06 across.
When confronted with excessive information and time constraints, "mental shortcuts" may shape an HCP's treatment decisions.

SHORTCUT #3 - AVAILABILITY HEURISTIC

Top of Mind is Right of Mind

A physician consistently places Medication Y as the 3rd or 4th line of treatment, as he vividly remembers the story of another HCP who prescribed it as a 1st line treatment and witnessed severe side effects for the patient.

Left: One large circle with the text "Instances of no side effects from Medication Y" written inside. In front: one small circle with "One-time severe side effects" written inside. Arrow from small circle to the text "TOP OF MIND FOR HCP". To the right: "However, the severe side effects from using Medication Y as a 1st line treatment may have been one-time occurrence. HCP Brain Hack. HCPs brains prioritize memorable events even if the event has a low chance of recurrence."

So, how do we address these mental shortcuts?

While minimizing the use of these shortcuts with bite-sized, easily processed information is important, it may be too ambitious to eliminate them entirely:​​

  • As time constrained individuals, HCPs are bound to use short-cuts​​.
  • Shortcuts are not inherently bad; they are a natural way of making decisions, though sometimes these decisions are based on inaccurate information​.

Maybe the question we need to start asking is...

How can we make HCPs more aware of the shortcuts they may be using?

If HCPs recognize that, as humans, we often rely on mental shortcuts, they may take this into account when making treatment decisions. With increased awareness through continuous education, HCPs can consciously check in with themselves to ensure their decisions are well-informed, reducing the potential downfalls of mental shortcuts and leading to more accurate decision-making.

What else can influence our ability to make decisions?

Our mood!

A happy mood can lead to... Efficient and accurate decisions. Open mindedness & flexibility. Helping & generosity.

If mood influences human decision-making...

What does that mean for physicians who struggle with increased pressure and constraints on a day-to-day basis?

What we know:

As we consider the impact of daily stressors & mood on HCP behavior, let's remember that HCPs in a positive mood:

Three columns. Column 1: Interact more effectively and are talkative with patients. Column 2: Tend to prescribe less medication. Column 3: Exhibit more open mindedness and a willingness to consider alternatives while diagnosing patients.

Improving health care outcomes with a better mood

Ask yourself... As a practitioner, what changes can you make in your practice to improve your mood? As a patient, what can you do during a healthcare visit to create a positive mood for you and your physician? As a sales rep, how can you effectively engage with HCPs to educate them and uplift their mood?

Author: Zarah Ghulamhussain, Associate Strategist

Editor: Karen McCauley, CEO

Designer: Gabriel Lopes, Art director

Explore More Perspectives

Let’s Get In Touch!

Contact us